Thornton Holding Court.jpg

Thornton Hall

The Revolution Will Be Kuhnian.

Lack Of Ideology Case In Point: Joe The Plumber

John McCain elevated Joe the Plumber--a man famous for being rude--to conservative icon when, in a debate with Obama, he cited Joe as the type of American hurt by Obama's tax plan.

But does Joe the plumber have a system of ideas which justifies a smaller Federal Government and support for institutions like the church? Or is he just an asshole who wants what he wants--mostly guns--and who doesn't care one iota about theories of government?

From the American Prospect:

•Six years later, Joe the Plumber is still in the headlines. But he's moved way beyond protesting the president's tax plan. Following last weekend's tragic shooting rampage on the campus of the University of California-Santa Barbara, Wurzelbacher took it upon himself to pen an open letter to the victims' families, sensitively informing them that "as harsh as this sounds—your dead kids don't trump my constitutional rights."

•Wurzelbacher's remarks appeared to be a response to an impassioned speech by one of the victims' fathers, who told reporters that his son died because of "craven, irresponsible politicians" and the NRA. "They talk about gun rights," he said. "What about Chris's right to live?"

•But this is far from the last time that Wurzelbacher's big mouth has gotten him in hot water. McCain may have regretted elevating Joe the Plumber to campaign-trail celebrity when, touring through Ohio, Wurzelbacher enthusiastically endorsed a supporter's claim that a vote for Obama was a vote "for the death of Israel."

•Then Wurzelbacher actually went to Israel (as a reporter for a conservative company called "Pajamas Media"), declaring that he had "no agenda but the truth." During his two-week truth-telling tour, he decided that journalists had no business in war zones. "I liked back in World War I and World War II, when you’d go to the theater and you’d see your troops on the screen and everyone would be real excited and happy for them," he said. "Now everyone’s got an opinion and wants to down soldiers, our American soldiers, Israeli soldiers. I think media should be abolished from, you know, reporting."

•In 2010, Wurzelbacher bit the hand that beckoned him into the limelight, telling a radio host that McCain was "no public servant" and that Obama, while his ideology was "un-American," was one of the "more honest" politicians around.

•Two years later, Joe the Plumber decided to run for a congressional seat in Ohio, saying he was "not the kind of plumber who uses duct tape." During the campaign, he ran an ad that tied the Holocaust to—you guessed it—gun control. "In 1939 Germany established gun control; from 1939 to 1945, 6 million Jews, 7 million others, unable to defend themselves, were exterminated," he continued, before turning to the camera and announcing "I love America."

•When asked about his stance on undocumented immigrants at an event in Arizona later that summer, Wurzelbacher was, as usual, candid. "For years I’ve said, you know, put a damn fence on the border, going to Mexico and start shooting…that’s how I feel," he said. "I’m not going to hide it just because I’m running for office. I want the borders protected, and I’m very adamant about that."

•Following his defeat—and less than a month after the deadly shooting at a school in Newton, Connecticut—Wurzelbacher began to rail against gun control. Early in 2013, he launched a new conservative advocacy website dedicated to the preservation of assault weapons. To celebrate, he announced that he was giving away an AR-15 rifle. "Despite what national news commentators say, the AR-15 is NOT an 'assault weapon' or 'weapon of mass destruction," he wrote on the site.

An Academic Economist Wrote This Because, Why?

Economics Is Bunk